6 Common Ways Commercial Landlords Default on Broker Commission Agreements

Introduction

In commercial real estate, commission agreements between landlords and brokers are designed to ensure brokers are fairly compensated for their role in securing tenants. However, disputes over commission payments are all too common. When commercial landlords default on their obligations, brokers are often forced to fight for the compensation they’re rightfully owed.

In this article, we’ll cover six of the most common commission agreement defaults by commercial landlords, how to avoid them, and what steps brokers can take to recover unpaid commissions.

---

✅ 1. Failing to Pay the Broker’s Commission on Time

One of the most frequent defaults in commercial lease transactions is the landlord’s failure to pay the broker’s commission on time. Commission agreements typically specify when payment is due, which may occur:

• Upon lease signing,
• When the tenant takes possession, or
• Once rent payments commence.

However, landlords may delay or withhold payment due to cash flow issues, administrative mistakes, or disputes with the broker. These delays can cause significant financial strain on brokers.

🔹 How to Protect Your Commission:

• Ensure your commission agreement clearly defines payment timelines.
• Include late payment penalties to deter delays.
• Proactively track key payment dates and follow up with the landlord if payment is overdue.

---

💰 2. Underpayment or Partial Payment of the Commission

Landlords sometimes pay brokers less than the agreed-upon commission. This may occur due to:

• Miscalculations or deductions from the gross rent amount,
• Claims that the broker's efforts were insufficient, or
• Unilateral changes to the commission terms.

🔹 How to Prevent Commission Shortages:

• Ensure the commission agreement explicitly defines how the commission is calculated.
• Include language addressing renewals, extensions, and rent modifications.
• Keep detailed records of lease negotiations to support your claim.

---

🔁 3. Failure to Pay Commission on Lease Renewals or Extensions

Commission agreements often include provisions for brokers to receive commissions on lease renewals or extensions. However, some landlords attempt to avoid these payments by claiming that the broker’s services were only related to the original lease.

🔹 How to Protect Your Rights:

• Include clear language in the commission agreement covering renewals and extensions.
• Monitor the property for future renewals or modifications.
• If a landlord fails to pay on a renewal, send a formal demand letter.

---

🚫 4. Refusing to Pay Commission After a Tenant Defaults

A tenant’s default does not usually excuse a landlord from paying the broker’s commission. However, some landlords attempt to withhold payment, claiming that the broker should bear some responsibility for the tenant’s failure.

🔹 How to Safeguard Your Commission:

• Ensure your commission agreement states that the broker’s commission is due regardless of tenant default.
• Retain documentation proving you fulfilled your contractual obligations.
• If the landlord refuses to pay, seek legal representation.

---

🛑 5. Landlord Disputes the Broker’s Role in Securing the Lease

Landlords sometimes claim that the broker was not directly responsible for securing the tenant, especially if multiple brokers or parties were involved. This is a common tactic used to avoid paying commission.

🔹 How to Strengthen Your Case:

• Keep thorough records of all communications with the tenant and landlord.
• Obtain written confirmations of your role in the transaction.
• Include language in the commission agreement confirming your entitlement to payment.

---

✍️ 6. Unilateral Changes to the Commission Agreement

Landlords may attempt to modify the commission agreement after the fact by reducing the commission rate, altering payment terms, or imposing new conditions.

🔹 How to Prevent Unauthorized Changes:

• Ensure modifications must be in writing and signed by both parties.
• Reject any unilateral changes and insist on enforcing the original agreement terms.
• Consult with a commercial litigation attorney if necessary.

---

⚖️ Legal Remedies for Unpaid Broker Commissions

If a commercial landlord defaults on a commission agreement, you have legal options, including:

• Demand Letters
• Litigation
• Lien Rights
• Contractual Remedies